Bonding wood to styrene?
Moderators: DasPhule, Moderators
Bonding wood to styrene?
Title says it all folks. What glues or epoxies have you used to bond wood to styrene? I have a wooden structural frame that I intend to skin with sheet styrene, but am unsure how to attach it.
P@T
P@T
- Lt. Z0mBe
- Posts: 7311
- Joined: Thu May 29, 2003 1:46 pm
- Location: Balltown Kentucky, by God!
- Contact:
Pat,
This scratchbuild was built over a balsa skeleton. I had excellent results with good old Loctite super-glue gel.
Every piece of the model in contact with the balsa uses the Loctite CA gel and let me tell you, when trying to remove the .020-inch styrene from the wood, it would rip instead of come loose. The .040 stuff would rip the balsa away rather than break the bond.
I hope this helps.
Kenny
This scratchbuild was built over a balsa skeleton. I had excellent results with good old Loctite super-glue gel.
Every piece of the model in contact with the balsa uses the Loctite CA gel and let me tell you, when trying to remove the .020-inch styrene from the wood, it would rip instead of come loose. The .040 stuff would rip the balsa away rather than break the bond.
I hope this helps.
Kenny
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 2463
- Joined: Sat Jul 13, 2002 4:42 pm
- Location: Back home in Cincy!
- Contact:
I would say contact cement if you are not concerned with the longevity of the model. The problem with most contact cements is that they can be affected by heat, humidity, etc. If you use a "hardcore" contact cements like those used in the flooring industry are not likely to be effected the same way but are seriously more caustic, there fore likely to melt your styrene sheet.
What I would do is create a stable base to glue the styrene to the wood. What I have done in the past is to put a skim coat of 2 ton epoxy on the wood and let it harden (I use the 2 ton because it is a stronger adhesive than 5 min. and the working time is about 20 to 30 min. This will give you plenty of time to spread it out evenly with a palette knife). Then rough up the face of the styrene that will be in contact with the "skimmed" wood. A pass with 60 or 80 grit will give you a great "tooth" for the 2 ton epoxy.
Then skim coat both surfaces and let them set up for 20 min. put the styrene in place and tape/ clamp/pin it in place. An hour later you should be good to go and have a stable base to detail as you see fit.
Hope this helps.
Mark
What I would do is create a stable base to glue the styrene to the wood. What I have done in the past is to put a skim coat of 2 ton epoxy on the wood and let it harden (I use the 2 ton because it is a stronger adhesive than 5 min. and the working time is about 20 to 30 min. This will give you plenty of time to spread it out evenly with a palette knife). Then rough up the face of the styrene that will be in contact with the "skimmed" wood. A pass with 60 or 80 grit will give you a great "tooth" for the 2 ton epoxy.
Then skim coat both surfaces and let them set up for 20 min. put the styrene in place and tape/ clamp/pin it in place. An hour later you should be good to go and have a stable base to detail as you see fit.
Hope this helps.
Mark
"Tell me and I forget. Teach me and I remember. Involve me and I learn."
- Benjamin Franklin
"I am recalibrating my lack of faith in humanity. I start by reading opinions on message boards…"
- Dogbert
"What is his Comprehension level? Are we talking Human, Squirrel or Anvil?"
- Dilbert
- Benjamin Franklin
"I am recalibrating my lack of faith in humanity. I start by reading opinions on message boards…"
- Dogbert
"What is his Comprehension level? Are we talking Human, Squirrel or Anvil?"
- Dilbert
- Chacal
- Posts: 3654
- Joined: Fri Jul 12, 2002 3:09 pm
- Location: Rio. Always unseasonably warm, even in the Winter, when we'll host the Summer Olympic Games of 2016
If you're skinning styrene over a wood shape, remember that if the styrene is to be formed over the wood (say a wooden cylinder with styrene sheet wrapped around it – your basic "hull" deal), the ends of the sheet will try to come loose. You might bolt them on or just glue a strip to cover the gap.
I would second Mark's suggestion (I like working with epoxy), but if your wood is balsa, it may be too porous and weak to stay put – the wood might come apart instead of the glue. In that case I'd suggest you prime the balsa (or any open-grained) wood with resin. Mix a small batch and "paint" it on with a disposable brush. The more porous your wood is, the better it will suck the resin up, and that's good, because the more porous the wood is, the more it needs resin reinforcement. After the resin cures, sand it and the surface should be excellent for gluing.
[edit]I forgot to mention that epoxy adhesives are usually too viscous to penetrate deep into the pores of balsa wood, so they make a surface layer of epoxy (half to one milimeter), while resin penetrates waaay deeper (in some cases up to four milimeters), making a composite – cellulose fiber reinforced resin – so to speak, which is much harder to pull apart.
I would second Mark's suggestion (I like working with epoxy), but if your wood is balsa, it may be too porous and weak to stay put – the wood might come apart instead of the glue. In that case I'd suggest you prime the balsa (or any open-grained) wood with resin. Mix a small batch and "paint" it on with a disposable brush. The more porous your wood is, the better it will suck the resin up, and that's good, because the more porous the wood is, the more it needs resin reinforcement. After the resin cures, sand it and the surface should be excellent for gluing.
[edit]I forgot to mention that epoxy adhesives are usually too viscous to penetrate deep into the pores of balsa wood, so they make a surface layer of epoxy (half to one milimeter), while resin penetrates waaay deeper (in some cases up to four milimeters), making a composite – cellulose fiber reinforced resin – so to speak, which is much harder to pull apart.
Sheer elegance in its simplicity.
Political unrest in dictatorships is rather like a round of rock-paper-scissors: The oposition goes on denouncing the regime on the papers, the regime censors the papers, rock-throwing ensues.
Political unrest in dictatorships is rather like a round of rock-paper-scissors: The oposition goes on denouncing the regime on the papers, the regime censors the papers, rock-throwing ensues.
..... or bind the styrene around your wooden core with tape and dip it in boiling water for a few seconds. It'll hold the same shape once the tape is removed and won't need any mechanical fastening other than the glue.If you're skinning styrene over a wood shape, remember that if the styrene is to be formed over the wood (say a wooden cylinder with styrene sheet wrapped around it – your basic "hull" deal), the ends of the sheet will try to come loose. You might bolt them on or just glue a strip to cover the gap.
Epoxy is good but slow. Thick superglue is probably the best. Contact adhesive like Evo-Stik has a strong solvent in it which may melt and distort areas of the styrene particularly if it's thin sheet. If you're sticking it to a frame i.e. at edges only, which your question suggests, just go with superglue.
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 2463
- Joined: Sat Jul 13, 2002 4:42 pm
- Location: Back home in Cincy!
- Contact:
One thing I forgot to mention is that you will need to be aware of bubbles particularly if you use the contact cement. I wouldmake sure to gat a narrow roller and lay the sheet down starting at one end and rolling out the extra air as you go. If you get a buble you are likely to have a heck of a time getting it to lay down.
"Tell me and I forget. Teach me and I remember. Involve me and I learn."
- Benjamin Franklin
"I am recalibrating my lack of faith in humanity. I start by reading opinions on message boards…"
- Dogbert
"What is his Comprehension level? Are we talking Human, Squirrel or Anvil?"
- Dilbert
- Benjamin Franklin
"I am recalibrating my lack of faith in humanity. I start by reading opinions on message boards…"
- Dogbert
"What is his Comprehension level? Are we talking Human, Squirrel or Anvil?"
- Dilbert
You may find epoxy does the same thing if you don't roughen the plastic sheet first. You'll get a better bond with epoxy but it can still separate. This sounds counter intuitive but try balsa cement in a tube. You can stick ABS with balsa cement. Some of the old Graupner glider kits provided ABS fuselages and canopy frames which could be stuck with UHU Hart (balsa cement). The "S" of ABS is "S"tyrene so it's worth trying. I wouldn't use it for laminating sheets though because it's air drying. Plastic to Balsa would be fine because the cemernt solvent soaks into the wood. On an open frame with airspaces it wouldn't be a problem. I still think superglue offers the path of least resistence though.
You don't need to seal the wood with PVA. You'd be better spreading thin superglue over the wood to seal it and then there's no bonding issues. You can smooth the wood with fine abrasive paper after the superglue has soaked in and set which you won't be able to do with PVA on it. Then you can glue your plastic sheet down with more superglue.
- rocketrider
- Posts: 869
- Joined: Wed Mar 09, 2005 5:03 pm
- Location: Moline, IL
- Contact:
You can try some stuff called Liquid Nails I have used it to bond wood to steel & plastic to carpet, and it has held great. (dries quickly though).
I believe you can get this at a local hardware store, and costs around $3-$5 a tube.
Glen
I believe you can get this at a local hardware store, and costs around $3-$5 a tube.
Glen
-
- Posts: 1042
- Joined: Tue Mar 02, 2004 7:49 pm
-
- Moderator
- Posts: 2463
- Joined: Sat Jul 13, 2002 4:42 pm
- Location: Back home in Cincy!
- Contact:
P@T,
I think the 2 ton epoxy might be your best bet as you are not likely to get any warping of fthe styrene (provided the gaps in your frame work are not too big).
Just my 2 cents,
Mark
I think the 2 ton epoxy might be your best bet as you are not likely to get any warping of fthe styrene (provided the gaps in your frame work are not too big).
Just my 2 cents,
Mark
"Tell me and I forget. Teach me and I remember. Involve me and I learn."
- Benjamin Franklin
"I am recalibrating my lack of faith in humanity. I start by reading opinions on message boards…"
- Dogbert
"What is his Comprehension level? Are we talking Human, Squirrel or Anvil?"
- Dilbert
- Benjamin Franklin
"I am recalibrating my lack of faith in humanity. I start by reading opinions on message boards…"
- Dogbert
"What is his Comprehension level? Are we talking Human, Squirrel or Anvil?"
- Dilbert
To clarify my prior post, I did pre-sand the bits of plastic before trying the polyurethane glue, It just doesn't seem to stick to styrene.
I'm surprised the contact cement failed. I used LePage's 'Green' non-toxic contact cement on a foam USS Voyager to glue thin styrene sheet accent panels, they're still on after 3 or 4 years.
I'm surprised the contact cement failed. I used LePage's 'Green' non-toxic contact cement on a foam USS Voyager to glue thin styrene sheet accent panels, they're still on after 3 or 4 years.
Stand back, I don't know how big this thing gets.
-
- Posts: 1037
- Joined: Fri Jul 12, 2002 7:21 pm
okay, i know you are not going to like this answer and think it would be too difficult, ....
but vacuforming will guarantee that it will be snug as a bug in the rug. keep your shapes simple. then glue on your doo dads on to the plastic to finish out the model. you can leave the wood in the vacuform, or remove. you can fill the vacuform with resin or plaster of paris, or leave open.
vacuforming is a lot easier than some would have you believe.
a 4'x8' sheet of styrene plastic would be less than $20. if you use .020 plastic sheet, then the thickness of the sheet will be reduced to about half of that or around .012, once it is vacuformed ovver your blank/part.
but vacuforming will guarantee that it will be snug as a bug in the rug. keep your shapes simple. then glue on your doo dads on to the plastic to finish out the model. you can leave the wood in the vacuform, or remove. you can fill the vacuform with resin or plaster of paris, or leave open.
vacuforming is a lot easier than some would have you believe.
a 4'x8' sheet of styrene plastic would be less than $20. if you use .020 plastic sheet, then the thickness of the sheet will be reduced to about half of that or around .012, once it is vacuformed ovver your blank/part.